Why is citizenship recognition so important for stateless adopted children?

Question

Accepted Answer

The Critical Importance of Citizenship Recognition for Stateless Adopted Children

Citizenship recognition for stateless adopted children is paramount due to the fundamental rights and opportunities it confers, which are otherwise denied to non-citizens. A stateless child, even when legally adopted by Malaysian parents, faces significant limitations in accessing essential services and participating fully in society. The absence of citizenship can lead to a life of exclusion, impacting their ability to pursue education, secure employment, access healthcare, and even travel freely. Without this legal status, such children are effectively in limbo, unable to claim the basic entitlements that citizens take for granted, thus hindering their development and integration.
Legal Adoption Does Not Automatically Confer Citizenship

While a Malaysian couple legally adopted the boy, identified as C, through a court order in July 2017, this adoption did not automatically grant him citizenship. Upon issuing a new birth certificate in September 2017, the National Registration Department (NRD) designated C's nationality as bukan warganegara (non-citizen), indicated by a red birth certificate. This status persisted despite the adoptive parents being Malaysian citizens and the child being born in Malaysia in January 2004 to unknown biological parents. The NRD's decision highlights a legal nuance where adoption, while establishing parentage, does not inherently supersede citizenship laws.
Denial of Basic Rights and Opportunities

The implications of being recognised as a non-citizen are far-reaching and severely restrict an individual's life prospects. For a child like C, the lack of Malaysian citizenship means he cannot obtain a Malaysian passport, thereby limiting his freedom to travel abroad. Furthermore, as a non-citizen, he is barred from attending public schools and universities, receiving medical treatment at government facilities, opening bank accounts, accessing banking facilities, purchasing insurance, and registering his marriage. These restrictions effectively render him stateless, as he is not a citizen of any other country but is denied the rights of citizenship in the country of his birth and upbringing.
Legal Recourse and Constitutional Questions

C's adoptive parents have pursued legal avenues for three years to secure his citizenship, facing dismissals from the High Court on July 3, 2019, and the Court of Appeal on July 1, 2020. However, the Federal Court has granted C leave to appeal, agreeing to hear five critical questions of law. These questions delve into whether C is a citizen by operation of law under specific articles of the Federal Constitution, particularly Article 14(1)(b) and Part II Section 1(e) and Section 2(3). The court will examine whether proof of biological parents' identity and citizenship is required under Part II Section 1(e), and whether the term "parents" in Part II Section 1(a) should be exclusively interpreted as biological parents. The legal standing of birth certificates issued under the Adoption Act 1952 for determining parentage will also be reviewed.
The Challenge of Statelessness and Article 15A

The adoptive father has highlighted that C is effectively stateless, a condition that carries profound disadvantages. While an application for citizenship registration under Article 15A of the Federal Constitution exists for individuals under 21, it is a discretionary process with no guaranteed outcome and can involve lengthy waiting periods of two years or more for a response. C's parents had applied under Article 15A in November 2018 when he was 14, but there has been no response. This uncertainty underscores the critical need for clarity and definitive legal recognition of citizenship for stateless adopted children, ensuring they are not denied fundamental rights due to their unique circumstances.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why is citizenship recognition so important for stateless adopted children?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends