Why might furlough schemes fail leisure and travel sector workers?

Question

Accepted Answer

Furlough Schemes May Prove Insufficient for Leisure and Travel Sector Workers Amidst Prolonged Pandemic Recovery

Temporary unemployment schemes across Europe, while instrumental in cushioning the initial economic shock of the Covid-19 pandemic, may ultimately fall short in safeguarding jobs within the leisure and travel sectors. This limitation arises primarily because these sectors are anticipated to experience prolonged or only partial recoveries, rendering the temporary nature of furlough schemes inadequate to sustain employment through an extended downturn. While such schemes have successfully supported millions of workers, their effectiveness is intrinsically linked to the speed of economic rebound, a factor that appears uncertain for industries heavily reliant on consumer confidence and mobility.
Limitations of Temporary Layoff Schemes in Slow-Rebounding Sectors

The core efficacy of temporary layoff or furlough schemes, such as Germany's "kurzarbeit," lies in their ability to provide a substantial portion of wages for workers during periods of no immediate work, with an expectation of a swift return. This model has proven beneficial for industries capable of rapid recovery, exemplified by the auto industry's resumption of operations. However, sectors like tourism and entertainment are not projected to exhibit a "V-shaped" recovery, meaning their return to pre-pandemic levels of activity is likely to be gradual and potentially protracted. Consequently, schemes with finite durations, like Italy's 18-week limit or the general end-of-June deadlines observed in many countries, may expire before these industries can reabsorb their workforce.
Substantial Costs and Projected Unemployment Increases

The financial burden of these extensive furlough programs is considerable. In the United Kingdom, the monthly cost to cover 7.5 million workers is estimated at £8 billion, a figure the Chancellor has acknowledged as unsustainable, despite extensions to the scheme. Even with these substantial outlays, projections indicate significant rises in unemployment rates; for instance, the UK anticipates its unemployment rate to more than double to 10% in the second quarter. Similarly, France's government is planning to reduce state wage reimbursements from June, indicating a recognition of the fiscal strain.
Evidence of Job Risks Post-Furlough

A study conducted in Belgium offers a stark preview of the potential fallout once temporary layoffs cease. With approximately 900,000 individuals covered by such schemes until the end of June, a company survey indicated that 180,000 workers, or 6% of the workforce, faced the risk of job loss in the near future. A significant portion of these at-risk individuals were employed in hotels, cafes, and restaurants (25%), with almost half working in the culture and recreation sectors. This suggests that even with government support, the underlying economic fragility of these sectors poses a persistent threat to employment.
Necessity for Alternative Solutions in Prolonged Crises

The limitations of furlough schemes become more pronounced when the economic crisis extends beyond a year. In such scenarios, economists suggest that alternative strategies, including retraining programs and different policy interventions, will be essential. This is particularly relevant for sectors that may undergo more fundamental, long-term shifts rather than simply experiencing a temporary lull. For instance, the aviation industry has already seen substantial job losses, and there is an acknowledgement that post-Covid-19 economic landscapes might necessitate a re-evaluation of sectoral capacities and potential permanent changes in consumer behaviour, such as a sustained shift towards online retail.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why might furlough schemes fail leisure and travel sector workers?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends