Why was Lee Zii Jia approved to turn pro but Goh Jin Wei was banned?

Question

Accepted Answer

Lee Zii Jia Approved to Turn Professional While Goh Jin Wei Was Banned Due to Discrepancies in Handling Player Departures

The Badminton Association of Malaysia (BAM) approved Lee Zii Jia's request to turn professional while imposing a ban on Goh Jin Wei, a decision that raises questions about the association's handling of players leaving the national squad. While both players resigned from BAM, the differing outcomes suggest an inconsistent application of policies regarding player departures, with historical precedents and the potential for an appeal appearing to influence the decisions.
Lee Zii Jia's Resignation Approved Following Appeal

Lee Zii Jia, the world number seven and All-England champion, had his request to turn professional approved by BAM. The article suggests this approval may have been influenced by Zii Jia submitting an appeal to the association. This implies that his departure was processed differently, potentially due to the act of appealing his situation.
Goh Jin Wei's Ban Contrasts with Precedents

Goh Jin Wei, a two-time world junior champion, was banned a week prior to Zii Jia's approval, despite both players having resigned from BAM. The article argues that Jin Wei's approval should have been granted without the need for an appeal, highlighting a perceived inconsistency. BAM's stated rationale for such bans is to discourage players from leaving the national squad prematurely and to uphold the institution's integrity, referred to as its "sanctity."
Historical Departures Did Not Result in Bans

The practice of banning players who leave BAM is not a long-standing, immutable rule. Several notable players have departed the national association without facing penalties. For instance, in December 2018, former world number three pair Chan Peng Soon and Goh Liu Ying resigned to become independent players, and no action was taken against them. Shortly thereafter, in January 2019, former world number one doubles pair Goh V Shem and Tan Wee Kiong also left BAM and were not punished. Furthermore, in the 1980s, the Sidek brothers left BAM to establish Nusa Mahsuri, Malaysia's first professional badminton club, without any repercussions.
Focus Should Be on National Success, Not Institutional Preservation

The article posits that BAM should not impede its successful players from pursuing professional careers. If players choose to leave for other stables, their subsequent achievements and medals won for Malaysia should be the priority. Winning for Malaysia, represented by the national flag on their shirts, is ultimately more significant than the internal policies of BAM. The association should aim to be recognized for producing numerous talented players who continue to bring glory to the nation, rather than restricting their opportunities.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why was Lee Zii Jia approved to turn pro but Goh Jin Wei was banned?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends