Why was the student fined RM70,000 for unlicensed dental services?

Question

Accepted Answer

High Court Upholds RM70,000 Fine for Unlicensed Dental Services

The High Court upheld a RM70,000 fine against a vocational college student for operating a dental service without a licence, deeming the penalty appropriate given the case's virality on social media and as a lesson to the public. The court considered the student's future and her employment status, ultimately dismissing the prosecution's appeal for imprisonment.
Social Media Virality Influenced Decision

The High Court judge, Datuk Ahmad Nasfy Yasin, specifically cited the case's widespread attention on social media as a factor in upholding the Sessions Court's decision. This public visibility underscored the need for the fine to serve as a clear deterrent, reinforcing respect for judicial pronouncements among both the offender and the general public.
Consideration of Offender's Circumstances

In reaching its decision, the court took into account the vocational college student's personal circumstances, including her future prospects and the fact that she was not currently employed. This evaluation of her situation contributed to the court's decision to maintain the monetary penalty rather than imposing a custodial sentence.
Dismissal of Imprisonment Appeal

The prosecution had appealed for a custodial sentence, but this was dismissed by the High Court. The court reasoned that the student had demonstrably learned her lesson and had provided a commitment not to repeat such an offence. This acknowledgment of her remorse and promise of future compliance was pivotal in the rejection of the imprisonment appeal.
Original Conviction and Legal Basis

The student, Nur Farahanis Ezatty Adli, was originally fined RM70,000, with an alternative of six months' jail, by the Sessions Court on September 29 last year. She had pleaded guilty to operating a dental clinic without a licence at Bakti Homestay, Jalan Bukit Katil, on January 25 of the same year. The charge was brought under Section 4(1) of the Private Healthcare Facilities and Services Act 1998, which allows for penalties of up to RM300,000, imprisonment for up to six years, or both.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why was the student fined RM70,000 for unlicensed dental services?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends