Why were election petitions for Masjid Tanah and Kemaman reinstated?

Question

Accepted Answer

Federal Court Orders Full Hearing for Masjid Tanah and Kemaman Election Petitions

The Federal Court has ordered election petitions challenging the results for the Masjid Tanah and Kemaman parliamentary constituencies in the 15th General Election (GE15) to be reinstated and sent back to the High Courts for a full hearing. This decision came after a three-member panel, led by Chief Justice Tun Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat, allowed appeals against the earlier decisions by Election Courts to strike out these petitions. The primary basis for allowing the appeals was the finding that the pleadings within the election petitions were sufficiently detailed to warrant a substantive examination of the claims.
Insufficient Grounds for Striking Out Petitions

The Election Courts in Melaka and Terengganu had previously dismissed the petitions filed by Barisan Nasional (BN) candidate Abdul Hakim Abdul Wahid for Masjid Tanah and voter Wan Mohamad Hisham Wan Abdul Jalil for Kemaman. These dismissals were based on preliminary objections raised by the respondents, arguing that the petitions lacked specific particulars, particularly regarding allegations of bribery. However, the Federal Court determined that the allegations, as presented in the pleadings, were substantial enough to proceed to a full trial rather than being summarily dismissed.
Allegations of Bribery Warrant Further Investigation

Abdul Hakim Abdul Wahid, the BN candidate for Masjid Tanah, alleged that bribery in the form of money and banquets was used to influence voters during GE15. He is challenging the victory of Bersatu's Datuk Mas Ermieyati Samsudin, who secured the Masjid Tanah seat with a majority of 4,411 votes. Similarly, the Kemaman election petition, filed by voter Wan Mohamad Hisham Wan Abdul Jalil, sought to nullify the results for the Kemaman parliamentary constituency. PAS's Che Alias Hamid had won this seat with a significant majority of 65,714 votes. The Federal Court's decision implies that these bribery allegations, as initially pleaded, require a thorough investigation.
Scheduling for Full Hearings Announced

Following the Federal Court's ruling, specific dates have been set for the mention of these cases in the respective Election Courts. The Masjid Tanah election petition is scheduled for mention on May 5, while the Kemaman election petition will be mentioned on May 8. These mentions will likely pave the way for the appointment of new Election Court judges and the commencement of full hearings on the merits of the challenges to the GE15 results in these two constituencies.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why were election petitions for Masjid Tanah and Kemaman reinstated?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends