Why were major holidays like Hari Raya not opened up if Covid-19 numbers can be spiked?

Question

Accepted Answer

Major holidays like Hari Raya were not opened up even if Covid-19 numbers could be “spiked” for election timing
The argument presented is that if the government could adjust Covid-19 figures “on demand” ahead of election time, it would be inconsistent for major holidays to remain shut instead of being used to reopen the country. The text points specifically to Hari Raya 2020 and Hari Raya 2021, saying both were cancelled or did not happen as usual.
The claim hinges on “on demand” manipulation, yet Raya 2020 and 2021 were cancelled
The discussion challenges the idea of election-driven number manipulation by asking why any “opening” would not have been timed for Hari Raya. It states that Hari Raya 2020 and Hari Raya 2021 were cancelled or not held in the normal way, which would contradict a scenario where authorities could simply raise or lower reported case numbers to fit a political calendar.
A reopening during Raya would likely have matched the logic used to defend election-timing conspiracies
The text frames Hari Raya as a very important holiday where allowing inter-state travel could have improved public sentiment. It therefore asks why figures would be manipulated only around Johor polls instead of being “unleashed” during Raya 2020 and 2021, when travel restrictions would be relaxed if the manipulation premise were true.
The text treats the Raya cancellations as a key inconsistency in the “spike” theory
The reasoning is that a theory claiming numbers can be controlled requires multiple conditions to align, and the Raya cancellations are presented as one of the hard-to-explain mismatches. If reported numbers can be altered to suit election timing, the text argues it becomes unclear why the same approach was not applied during two separate Raya periods.
The question is posed to show how the theory needs more and more explanations
The passage repeatedly asks “why” questions to show that sustaining the conspiracy account requires further and further assumptions. It adds that the Johor polls are on March 12, and uses the timeline to question why any supposed withholding from December would not continue closer to the election if the approach were truly about managing turnout.

Reading history

Hide →

This history is cleared when the page is closed.

Why were major holidays like Hari Raya not opened up if Covid-19 numbers can be spiked?

Loading

Was this article helpful?

Helpful

Not helpful

Report an issue

1

0

0

Share with friends